Cooking the Books? How to Know When Companies Boost Earnings Artificially

cooking books

Experienced investors have heard of now-bankrupt companies such as WorldCom and Enron. Both participated in scandalous accounting schemes.

Neither company exists today, but each left a trail of losses that are still keenly felt. Many employees had their life savings in company stock quickly made worthless.

The scandals involved tricks that these companies used and some still use today to make their financial situations seem better than reality.

By design, accounting standards are open to a lot of interpretation. This gives managers flexibility on how they report earnings or revenues.

Wall Street focuses strongly on quarterly earnings reports. The big investors obsess over whether companies might report better-than-expected or worse-than-expected earnings. Small changes in investor sentiment can affect positions valued in the billions.

However, astute investors view these periodic reports with caution. 

Managers, of course, are driven to please shareholders. Their compensation and, by extension, their jobs depend on keeping investors happy. This relationship should drive efficiency and excellency, but it can encourage management to use accounting tricks instead to artificially boost earnings — or even participate in fraud. 

Investors may hear managers use the term “earnings management.” It’s just another term for manipulated earnings.

Company managers may attempt to manipulate earnings or revenues, depending on what they want to accomplish. For instance, an investor may want to investigate whenever changes in accounting procedures occur.

Companies that sell products might change the procedures for the movement of goods. When a company uses last-in, first-out (LIFO), the costs associated with this method will be different for first-in, first-out (FIFO). 

For instance, raw materials might be contracted but not shipped, so a cost is not yet recognized. Lower costs can make short-run earnings seem better, triggering bonuses in the C-suite.

Or, goods might be sold to a distributor and counted as revenue but then remain unsold in the distribution chain for many months. Goods pile up. Eventually, new sales halt as distributors choke on inventory.

A one-time change in movement of goods accounting for tax advantage reasons could be a good move for shareholders. If so, such a change eventually will trickle through. Yet if the company flip-flops on procedures regularly, that’s a red flag.

Revenue recognition is another area ripe for manipulation. Many companies are required to use accrual accounting when they reach a certain size.

With this method, they must match expenses during a given period to the revenues earned for that period. They must also recognize the revenues when the products or services have been delivered. There’s enough gray area here to make revenue seem better or worse in any given quarter.

What caused earnings to increase?

When earnings increase substantially, it may be time to dig more into the reasons why.

  • Did company management announce significant initiatives in previous periods that would account for the surge in earnings?
  • Has the company been boosting its research and development budget that could explain why earnings have increased?
  • Have there been capital expenditures for new equipment or land that could explain the earnings situation?

Management should explain any developments that may have led to increases in earnings. Listen to management discussions on earnings calls, or read the transcripts when they are published.

Investors should read through earnings footnotes diligently. Companies know that most investors won’t read through these crucial details of the financial statements.

Often, companies can escape regulatory scrutiny by disclosing out-of-the-ordinary situations in the footnotes. For some managers, that is the purpose of footnotes — to hide the ugly truth of what’s going on.

Responsible management teams use footnotes with discretion. When investors find managers constantly posting to footnotes, that could be an indication management is looking to manipulate financial reality.

Companies can be justified in taking certain actions. As an investor, however, you are not required to stick with the company if those actions cause you discomfort.

It’s your money. If something seems out of place, you have the right to take action yourself. You can sell the stock, avoid investing in the company or reduce your investment substantially.

pot stock

Pot Stock ‘Blood in the Streets’ Buy Signal Is Here

The cannabis market has been a volatile space in recent years. A wave in legalization, particularly in Canada but also through parts of the United States, led to significant growth

Use Options as Portfolio Insurance in Rocky Times

Since the beginning of September we have seen the main U.S. indices drop. There are a number of possible reasons for the decline, but more importantly I expect the increased

4 Foreign Countries Where You Can Retire On Social Security Alone

Someone once said that retirement is not the end of the road but a highway opening to a new chapter in life. Whoever said that clearly has never experienced a

We’re Beating the Index Off the March Low: Update

The Bulletproof Wealth Report model portfolio is continuing to perform well and is now up 27.4% since the inception of our monthly newsletter on April 13, 2018. Although the value

Terrible Tuesday: Fed’s Powell Says U.S. Faces Slow, Uncertain Recovery

Powell testifies before Congress today. We already know what he's going to say though, as his testimony is pre-released. Not that that will stop the market from acting shocked when

5 Best Online Banks, Highest Savings Rates for Your Buck

Finding an online bank can be difficult. Varying rates, hidden fees and simply having too many choices can cause confusion and make it hard to get started. Set aside some

Hiring a Financial Advisor: What Is a Fiduciary, and Why Should You Care?

“Fiduciary” is a funny word. You may have never heard of it until now, but you may actually have had a fiduciary in your life. More importantly, you may wish

Trading Cryptocurrency Using Limit and Stop Orders

This is the last of a five-part series to help new investors and traders start and grow a cryptocurrency account. In all five articles I’ve been using Bitcoin (BTC) in

3 Cheap ETFs Combine to Create a Powerful Value Stock Opportunity

As I steadily increase my overall equity exposure to a measurable value bias, I do so using just three passive ETFs that are consistently near the top of their respective

Options: This ETF Could Bring a Triple-Digit Gain as the Economy Gains Steam

If we go back to February 19, when the S&P 500 peaked at what was an all-time high at the time, the market has gone through five phases since then.

dividend stock investing

Make Money While You Sleep with Dividend Stock Investing

Famed investor Warren Buffett once said, "If you don't find a way to make money while you sleep, you will work until you die." Dividend stock investing is a exactly

5 Ways to Slash Your Food Spending and Save Money

The average American spends up to 10 percent of their disposable income on food, according to the USDA. Things are likely different due to the coronavirus, but the typical divide