Investing With a Conscience: Increasingly, Socially Responsible Funds Keep Up Just Fine

Investors with ethical concerns can now put their money where their mouth is — and still enjoy lucrative returns.

Ethical investment approaches — sometimes called socially responsible investing (SRI), environmental, social and governance (ESG) or simply sustainable investing — have seen an increase in interest from both retail and institutional investors. 

The world’s largest investment manager, BlackRock, has now created several options for investors who want to avoid funding gunmakers and gun retailers in the wake of the recent U.S. school shooting in Parkland, Florida.

BlackRock also offers a range of socially responsible mutual and exchange traded funds, that have historically excluded arms manufacturers and cigarette companies, and ones which favor companies with a social bent.

Meanwhile, the number of socially responsible exchange-traded funds (ETFs) keeps on growing.

The most recent estimate puts one out of every five dollars under professional management in the United States in some variety of sustainable fund or investment practice, totaling $8.72 trillion, according to the Forum for Sustainable and Responsible Investment.

Ethical investing has long been seen as less lucrative than its less socially-minded equivalent. For instance, funds tracking only companies that sell weapons, alcohol, tobacco and gambling have long exceeded the broad market.

So-called “sin stocks” can provide a boost for equity investors. The Norwegian sovereign wealth fund, which managers $1 trillion in oil wealth on behalf of Norway’s citizens, found that excluding questionable stocks cost 0.1 percentage points of return per year over a decade.

It’s small difference in percentage but a huge number of dollars when you manage $1 trillion — about $4 billion in lost value.

Nevertheless, the same fund also found that excluding certain individual companies due to specific conduct problems had raised returns by 0.04 percentage points annually.

The Norwegian Finance Ministry, which broadened its ban to include big coal producers two years ago, is also questioning whether big oil companies should be excluded — a quandary for a fund that oversees wealth from oil drilling.

Price of conscience

Despite still being seen as an approach that entails sacrificing returns, ethical investment has evolved over the past few decades.

The adoption of environmental, social and governance standards by mainstream fund management has helped funds make money in a fast growing market while also making the world a better place.

Must you pay for a conscience when investing? Not necessarily.

A study by TIAA, a large fund manager in the United States, found that long-term rates of return between socially responsible funds and they market indexes were comparable, with no statistical differences.

Using social criteria did not increase risk, either. However, over short-term periods there could be differences in rates of return, known as “tracking error.”

That is, a fund that attempts to match an index, such as the S&P 500, while excluding problematic stocks might not match it exactly week to week or month to month. Over time, however, the returns would similar if not the same, the study found.

3 Quality Dividend-Paying Tech Stocks to Buy Now

The Federal Reserve has stated that it will keep printing money until it has achieved its dual mandate of full employment and 2% inflation. The Fed is nowhere near achieving

A Bottom for Energy? High Probability Bullish Signal for This ETF

Over the last few years the Energy Select Sector SPDR (XLE) has primarily trended lower with a few bursts of upward momentum sprinkled in at certain times. The pattern for

Weakening Wednesday: Presidential Debate Spooks the Market

Well that went as expected. Yesterday we titled our Morning Report: Testy Tuesday – Shorting the S&P 500 at 3,350 and we made a lovely $1,250 per contract on our

Warren Buffett’s Favorite Indicator Suggests a Stock Crash Is Coming

Anyone in the realm of finance or the stock market knows Warren Buffett. He is the billionaire CEO of Berkshire Hathaway and has been one of the world’s best investors

Some Expected a Junk Bond Explosion. The Data Says Different.

It has been well documented that much corporate debt has been downgraded by the rating services over the course of this pandemic slowdown. However, the actual data shows it not

Iaccino: Some Quick Stock Ideas for an Unsettled Market

RealDaily's Bob Iaccino recently appeared on the Alpha Trader podcast (available here). Co-founder of PureXposure Growth Series and Chief Strategist at Path Trading Partners, Bob writes The Stock Think Tank

biden wins

What I’m Telling Investors to Do If Biden Wins the White House

The value of our Bulletproof Wealth Report model portfolio declined modestly over the past several trading days ending Sept. 27, while the Dow Jones Industrial Average fell by 822 points

Options: Meandering Market Tamed by Using a Straddle or a Strangle

When you hear talk of markets trending, people think of uptrends or downtrends. However, markets often get stuck in a trading range. This is the condition where there is no

Warning! Market ‘Death Cross’ Appears

A death cross! According to Investopedia: The death cross is a technical chart pattern indicating the potential for a major selloff. The death cross appears on a chart when a

5 Best Stocks to Buy If Trump Wins the Election

If President Donald Trump wins the election on November 3, 2020, you might want to consider adding these five equities positions to your portfolio: LMT, BAC, AMZN, XLE, TWTR. Why?

5 Best Stocks to Buy If Biden Wins the Election

If Vice President Joe Biden wins the election on November 3, 2020, you might want to consider adding these five equities positions to your portfolio: XLU, TSLA, XLV, MLM, and

TGIF — Ending the Week with a Whimper

Everything is proceeding as I have foreseen. In Monday's "The Week Ahead — 200,000 Deaths Weigh Heavily on the Market," we knew the 200,000th American death would put Covid back