Opinion: Never Let a Robot Choose Your Investments

We live in a fast-paced world. This motivates many people to automate menial tasks, including investing.

That may work for a while, which gives you a false sense of security. This false sense then may entice you to commit more capital than you should.

If it works for $100 trades, it should work for $1,000 trades, right?. This is how greed sets in, and that can be the downfall of any portfolio.

Another problem is that other traders watch when something is working and pounce on it. They subscribe to the robotic trading program and reverse-engineer the software.

Then they hire someone who can produce code quickly and start using it for themselves or sell it to others. The net effect is that the process becomes less effective for everyone.

You might wonder how traders learn to reverse engineer each other’s systems. It all has to do with claims made by the companies programming the robots.

Wouldn’t you want to trade with someone who claims a 90% success rate? Scalping traders quickly steal these systems.

Then, there is the problem of intense competition among robot programmers. The more robots that exist the tougher it becomes to find ones that do work and who aren’t making egregious claims.

Passive vs. programmed

Iconic billionaire investor Warren Buffett made a bet back in 2007 that he could beat any company who engaged in active trading, including robotic trading.

The bet ended in 2017. The hedge fund company challenger conceded months before the bet was concluded.

Buffett used an index on the S&P 500. He was so far ahead that the hedge fund manager had no choice but to throw in the towel.

Why did Buffett win the bet? Part of the reason is that he didn’t overtrade. Every trade you make — or have a robot make for you — generates a commission for your broker.

This is something that will plague any robot-trading solution. Many robots trade in and out multiple times per day. The commissions on this alone will eat into the profits of most portfolios.

Buffett didn’t have this problem.

Furthermore, don’t confuse a robotic solution with passive investing. Buffett advises that people invest in an index fund, such as the S&P 500.

The returns of most investment pros eventually revert to the mean, and the mean is typically represented by an index fund.

Over the long run, then, most managers are incapable of beating the index.

Recommended Articles

Study Link Selfies To Mental Disorders: What You Need To Know

Everyone can admit to taking a "selfie" — aiming a smartphone camera at yourself — from time to time, whether it be alone or with a group of friends when

Opinion: Value Investing Is Dead? Not By a Long Shot

According to some, hunting for stocks that are undervalued as a basis for portfolio selection — commonly called value investing — has been out of favor as former value investors

4 Lies That Your Financial Advisor Will Tell You

If you are thinking about hiring a financial advisor — paying someone to manage your money for you — then you should be aware of the lies they might tell

Wealth Building Tips From Soros, Cuban, and Buffett

Billionaires George Soros, Warren Buffett, and Mark Cuban did not become rich accidentally. They made consistently smart investment decisions, which helped them create great personal wealth as well as economic

Exclusive: Market Think Tank Experts On the Year Ahead for Stocks

Watch this exclusive replay of the Market Think Tank with Bob Iaccino from the live event held January 25th. In this video replay, Amelia Bourdeau, Jim Iuorio, Mike Shorr, Michael

This Is How Your Birth Order Affects Your Personality

Many believe that the order you are born in affects your personality. By birth order I mean the oldest, middle, youngest or only child. Seems pretty obvious right that this could

5 Ways Billionaires Think Differently About Money

In 2016, according to PwC, the wealth of billionaires grew by 17 percent. If you aspire to be a billionaire, it pays to think and act like a billionaire. Here

Should High Earners Give Up Some of Their Social Security Benefits?

There is growing momentum that calls for Social Security benefits to be paid at a flat rate. This would be a huge departure from the current system. As it stands,

5 Valid Reasons You Should Never Eat Tilapia Again

Tilapia has become the ubiquitous fish in America today. It’s cheap, not “fishy” tasting, boneless and skinless, and is hard to mess up by overcooking, which is a problem with

Social Security Is Running Out of Money. What Can You Do About It?

The Social Security Administration announced on Tuesday that it expects to pay out more money than it takes in this year. That means that it will have to draw on

This State Will Pay You $10,000 to Move There — But There’s a Catch

Vermont Governor Phil Scott has signed into legislation that will pay people to relocate to the state in a bid to grow the state's flagging taxbase and reinvigorate the economy

See the World: How to Fund a Nomadic Retirement

According to the 18th Annual Transamerica Retirement Survey, 70% of American workers dream of a retirement spent travelling the world, visiting exotic locations and enjoying the diverse cultures of the