Opinion: Value Investing Is Dead? Not By a Long Shot

According to some, hunting for stocks that are undervalued as a basis for portfolio selection — commonly called value investing — has been out of favor as former value investors have embraced higher-risk growth stocks.

The idea of researching companies with the goal of buying stocks that are cheap or undervalued was an investing philosophy introduced by the legendary Benjamin Graham, whose most well-known disciple is Warren Buffett.

Value investing seeks to differentiate between the price of a stock and the value of the underlying business. The goal is to ascertain a stock’s intrinsic value, based on an analysis of a company’s current financial condition and its prospects for the future.

The investment principles espoused by Graham held that a share price that is below its intrinsic value is considered a bargain.

Now some argue that the precepts of value investing are no longer applicable as the tech stocks have appreciated substantially since the financial crisis. In many cases tech stocks now operate as market leaders, helping to consistently bring indexes to new highs.

These companies are different in that they are asset-light — they rely on either intellectual property or advertising tech business models.

Yet of the demise of value investing may be premature. Those who contend value investing is irrelevant in the 21st century due to the dominance of the growth or tech stocks sang the same song in the late 1990’s and 2000, during the dot.com craze.

That bubble burst with calamitous effects on those who thought the sky was the limit and traditional fundamental analysis was old-fashioned.

Further, purported “value” funds today suffer from some of the same flaws that Graham warned investors about in the late 1960’s and early 70’s.

Namely, portfolio managers are caught up in the herd mentality and are under constant pressure to dress up their fund’s performance or total return figures to remain competitive with other similar funds.

Often, this entails purchasing individual stocks for the portfolio that traditional value investors would avoid but are now included in the value fund.

Seeking out bargains in the market is in no way at odds of the phenomenal rise of technology stocks. Many of those who argue that value investing is dead base their arguments solely on the performance of the composition of stocks in broad stock market measures, such as the Dow Jones Industrial Average and the S&P 500 index.

There is also the factor of how one defines a “value” stock.

“One of the toughest things is being able to articulate what value investing is anymore,” said Laton Spahr, the portfolio manager of Oppenheimer’s value fund.

Blurred line

Indeed, his value fund has blurred the line between value and growth. Its portfolio has positions in Microsoft and UnitedHealth Group — two equities that are classified as growth stocks.

Purchasing a tech stock that has appreciated dramatically does not, in and of itself, mean it is still not a bargain. The determinative factor is whether its current price reflects the value of the business itself.

This measure is not dependent on the types of assets the company owns. Whether its main assets are intellectual property or advertising revenue as opposed to physical plant and machinery is irrelevant.

Amazon, for instance, is classified as a growth stock. But it could still be considered undervalued if the prospects for its continued earnings growth are not reflected in its current share price.

Another significant factor that were not present during the astronomical rise of the growth tech stocks was the absence of competition, which has created market dominance or a monopoly for each of the companies in their respective industries.

That laissez-faire attitude helped accelerate these companies’ earnings growth. Regulators are now scrutinizing the business practices of Google, Facebook and Amazon in order to ascertain if their rapid growth and business models stifles competition and makes it difficult for start-ups who might challenge their dominance.

Finally, the historically unprecedented zero interest rate environment of the past 10 years fueled the bull market and the tech stocks that rose in tandem.

A long-running low interest rate investment climate skewed asset pricing. Now that the Federal Reserve has announced that quantitative easing is over, bonds are beginning to appear more attractive and the presence of alternative fixed income vehicles for investors will have an impact on the stock market.

Those who claim that value investing is dead based solely on the performance of the stock market during the long bull run should be careful about predicting the future by merely extrapolating the past.

Recommended Articles

7 Warnings Signs of a Recession

The 2018 has not been a banner year for the stock market. Warning signs of a recession are becoming more obvious, according to some economists and market pundits. The Dow

Keeping More: How Does a Student Loan Affect Taxes?

Filling out your taxes correctly can be a challenging process, especially for those with student loans. But how does a student loan affect taxes? Many ways, starting with deductions. It

Migraine Pain? Here Are the Best and Worst Foods

Food can be your friend or your foe. Particularly for migraineurs, food can be a serious trigger for a headache, or it can bring a blessed relief from pain. Here

5 Major Money Decisions Before You Retire

It is said that retirement is a lifelong journey and not a destination. For many aspiring retirees, it may be a road to nowhere. Over 22% of Americans have less

Buying a Home? Avoid These 8 Killer Mistakes

Buying is home is not easy. You need to line up credit, decide how much house to buy, find the house, deal with realtors and the sellers. It can be

Body Odor: The Real Reasons Why You Stink

Body odor can be a really embarrassing condition. Unfortunately too many people deal with this common problem by washing more often with antibacterial soaps and body washes, and applying products

4 Powerful Passive Income Ideas That Can Boost Income

Do you enjoy exchanging hours for pay? This form of compensation is common, but most people dread it. What if you could instead get paid whether you work or not?

8 Tips for Efficiently Managing Your Small Business Finances

Managing your small business finances is crucial. Small to medium-sized businesses need financing but they lack enough of it — to the tune of $5 trillion, according to the SME Finance

The One Chart That Could Be a Game Changer for Investors

Allow me to present one chart to you that could indeed prove to be a game changer for investors and financial markets going forward. See below. What are we looking

6 Cultures That Promote Longer Lives and What We Can Learn From Them

Okinawa is renowned for its ability to produce long-living citizens and centenarians, or individuals who live past 100 years of age. What’s their secret? Their bodies age more slowly than

Seniors Finding Jobs in the Gig Economy Created by Millennials

A growing number of seniors finding jobs are doing so by joining the gig economy. According to a 2017 Prudential Financial survey, around 31 percent of gig economy workers are

Viagra for Women — Is a Pill Really the Best Answer for Igniting a Woman’s Sex Drive?

There is a new drug going up for FDA approval called Flibanserin. This medicine is being called “Viagra for women.” The FDA has already denied approval of this medication twice