Passive Investing Reigns, but Active Often Means Better Returns

Equity investors increasingly invest in funds with passive strategies.

Instead of using an active strategy of picking certain stocks, passive funds park money in assets with returns based on stock indexes reflecting the whole market, the good, the bad and everything in between.

But active strategies can outperform passive ones, not only in stock trades but also in real estate investments.

Morningstar reports that mutual funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are managing $6.8 trillion of assets under passive, index-based strategies, up from $2.7 trillion in 2013.

About a third of U.S. assets are managed under passive strategies, and the proportion is rising rapidly as more money moves to passive funds from actively managed funds.

Many active money managers have responded to the passive index-based trend by rolling out equity funds with so-called “focused strategies,” or funds with holdings in 50 or fewer stocks.

More than half of 91 institutional investors surveyed from September to November by Greenwich Associates and Fred Alger Management Inc. said they had increased their portfolio allocations to focused-strategy funds in the previous 18 months.

Part of the appeal of focused-strategy stock funds is the expectation that they include the stocks that the fund managers like best.

Returns on funds holding 50 or fewer stocks also are unlikely to correlate with returns on funds  with so many stocks that they mimic a stock index.

Jim Tambone, chief distribution officer of Fred Alger Management, said mathematical probability explains why focused strategies offer bigger potential returns than passive strategies.

The probability of outperforming the market is far greater with 10 stocks than with 1,000 “because once you’re at 1,000, you’re essentially the market,” Tambone said.

Active-strategy returns also can exceed passive-strategy returns in real estate investments.

Consider, for example, the acquisition and renovation of a rental apartment building. Whether a passive or an active investment strategy is best for such a project depends on which strategy best fits the investor.

A passive investor in an apartment project is a limited partner with no control over the business plan, so trust in the project’s sponsor is critical.

A passive investor can further reduce risk by insisting on a preferred return, an agreed-upon return that is paid before the sponsor collects any compensation.

An active property investor, by contrast, would exercise direct control over the plan for acquisition and renovation, over decisions about the type of tenants accepted and the rent charged, and ultimately, when or whether to refinance a property or sell it.

Along with taking more control, an active investor in a rental property project takes bigger risks and makes a bigger commitment of time than a passive investor. 

Among the common mistakes that expose active investors to large losses are underestimating renovation costs and overestimating rental income.

But obviously, the potential rewards are also greater for an active investor who owns 100 percent of a real estate project instead of sharing it with partners.

Recommended Articles

8 Unconventional and Fun Ways to Make Extra Money

The number one formula for making money is that there is no formula. In fact, if you are willing to move away from the traditional path to earn money you

Science Says the Perfect Female Body Should Look Like This

Everyone has their own opinion of what the female body should look like. Society and the media often exhibit women that are thin as the ideal womanly figure. This causes

Americans Are More Afraid of Doctor Bills Than They Are of Being Sick

The skyrocketing cost of healthcare has become prohibitive for many Americans. More people seem to be skipping physician visits, and U.S. healthcare costs rose to $10,000 a year per person in

Your Meat Is Treated with Carbon Monoxide to Make It Look Fresh

When you are looking for a nice steak, pork chops or chicken at your grocery store one of the main things you look for is the color of the meat.

Anxiety? 10 Foods You Should Be Eating (and What To Avoid!)

Occasional anxiety is a part of life. You may feel anxious when faced with a problem at work, before making a big change, or deciding on an important decision. But anxiety disorders

5 Gig Economy Tips That Will Help You Succeed

The gig economy has been expanding at a scorching pace, with some surveys indicating that nearly one in three American workers now participate in it, whether part-time or full-time. A

7 Genius Food Tricks You Can Do at Home

Everyone likes to have fun and cook, right? There are many cool hacks and tricks out there nowadays that make kitchen time more fun. Making time in the kitchen more

3 Powerful Ways to Invest in Mexico

Mexico has a rich and deep history that can be traced back thousands of years. The country has tourism hubs in the Caribbean and the Pacific, beautiful colonial towns and

Unclaimed Money: How to Find and Recover Your Lost 401(k) Money

A crisis is looming on the horizon — and it's not the same old story about workers who haven't saved enough. This calamity is affecting would-be retirees who can’t find

7 Profound Personal Finance Practices to Follow

Nearly 57% of American adults have savings of less than $1,000, while 39% have zero savings. Following a few quintessential personal finance practices, however, can help you achieve a healthier

FIRE Your Old Financial Life and Retire Early. Here’s How…

A Chicago flight attendant has hit the news for turning her financial life around. At 39, Bianca DiValerio was nearly broke after a divorce and the sale of several failing

Interview: Rates Will Stay Low, Uber ‘to the Moon’

Don't expect the Federal Reserve to even tap on the brakes anytime soon, says Bob Iaccino, editor of the Stock Think Tank. On Thursday, Fed Chairman Jerome threw cold water