Should High Earners Give Up Some of Their Social Security Benefits?

There is growing momentum that calls for Social Security benefits to be paid at a flat rate. This would be a huge departure from the current system.

As it stands, your Social Security benefit payment is based on three factors. These are:

  • How much income did you earn over your lifetime
  • The year in which you were born
  • At what age you decide to start taking money out 

This means that the average retired worker receives $1,500 a month in benefit payments from Social Security. The maximum benefit for someone at retirement age is slightly over $3,000.

As benefits are partly based on how much income you earn over your lifetime, those who earned more will receive more.

These benefit payments for high-income earners, while proportionally less based on the Social Security formula, are still of a greater magnitude than those benefits paid out to lower income workers.

The argument for “universal” Social Security — that everyone would receive the same income, regardless of working income — is that it would grant more assistance to people who live below the poverty line.

Of course, to make it work, those who earn a higher income would slowly see their benefits reduced. This kind of change would not happen overnight, and probably take a couple of decades.

Millennial dilemma

Millennials are increasingly planning for a retirement that doesn’t include Social Security. The Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania predicts that the Social Security fund may run out as soon as 2032.

The Bipartisan Policy Center, a Washington D.C. think tank, believes the fund could be exhausted as soon as 2028.

In response, the Heritage Foundation, a conservative think tank, has formulated its own plan as to what universal Social Security should look like.

It would include a tax break if you are self employed.  Right now, Social Security is funded through a payroll tax.

Self-employed, since they are both the employee and the employer, put 12.4% of their wages into the Social Security trust fund.

“We estimate that you could reduce the 12.4% tax down to 10%,” said Rachel Greszler, a research fellow at The Heritage Foundation.

“A median household ($68,700 per year) would have an extra $1,580 income each year to spend or save as best for them.”

Recommended Articles

6 Exotic Vacation Spots Where a Dollar Goes Farthest

The average cost for an American to go on vacation is just about $1,200. Depending on where you go, that cost might barely cover the airfare. That’s the thing about

4 Safe Ways to Earn Steady Retirement Income

Retirement should be a time to relax and experience the good things of life that you probably missed when you were working full-time. However, to have a truly good time

Restless Leg Syndrome — Is It All in Your Head?

If you’ve ever felt tingling, crawling or tugging sensations in your legs, seemingly for no reason at all, you might have thought you were going crazy. These feelings may keep

11 Money-Burning Impulse Buys You Must Resist

The average American spends over $5,400 every year on unnecessary impulse buys. Think about what you could do with an extra $5,400. Setting aside that amount in a retirement plan

5 Questions to Ask Before You Take Money from a 401(k)

Sometimes even the most financially prudent individuals may go through an unforeseen emergency that forces them to consider making an early retirement withdrawal. However, while in your moment of difficulty

10 Ways to Spend and Live Well With No Cash

Living a healthy lifestyle isn’t always easy, and it can weigh heavily on the wallet. Organic food can cost a pretty penny and holistic healthcare models are often paid out

Save Hundreds by Being Your Own Pest Control Service

The average cost of a pest control visit can be anywhere between $150 to about $1,500, depending on the severity of the problem. Most new homeowners don’t appreciate that when

How to Protect Your 401(k) in the Event of a Market Crash

It's normal for investors, especially those close to retirement age, to worry about fluctuations in the market and how it will affect their 401(k) plans. And while there's no way

Would You Eat Ugly Carrots to Save Money?

“Ugly produce” a is term for aesthetically unpleasing food that usually goes unsold in lieu of more cosmetically appetizing fruits and vegetables. Bruised, blemished, or misshapen apples, double-headed carrots, or

credit score boost

Credit Score Boost: How Your Behavior Affects Your Credit

A credit score is a lot like your personal economic statement. Getting a credit score boost improves your money life immediately. Any time you apply for a loan, a mortgage,

Retiring? Here’s 4 Cities Where You Can Live on $1,500 Monthly

Retirement should technically be a wondrous time of life where you stop living to work and start working on living. However, retirement in real life is nothing like the pop-culture

8 Things to Do the Moment You Start Feeling Sick

Some days, you just know something’s got you. When you feel that heaviness in your head, an aching in your joints or scratching in the back of your throat, it’s